| Year |
Name |
Honor |
Sport |
| 1997 |
Hellen Jelimo |
All-American |
Women's Cross Country |
| 1998 |
Scott Halley |
All-American |
Men's Outdoor Track & Field |
| 1999 |
Scott Halley |
All-American |
Men's Outdoor Track & Field |
| 2003 |
Nicole Brown |
All-American - Third Team |
Division II Women's Basketball |
| 2003 |
Sara Gamble |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Volleyball |
| 2004 |
Tara Anderson |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 2004 |
Alyssa Miller |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 2005 |
Tara Anderson |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 2005 |
Lisa Lyons |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 2005 |
Chris West |
Scholar-Athlete |
Men's Soccer |
| 2005 |
Danielle Selvidge |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Volleyball |
| 2006 |
Joseph Witzig |
Scholar-Athlete |
Men's Cross Country |
| 2006 |
Danielle Selvidge |
Scholar-Athlete |
Division II Women's Basketball |
| 2006 |
Martin McLaughlin |
Scholar-Athlete |
Men's Basketball |
| 2006 |
Jim Voeks |
Scholar-Athlete |
Men's Basketball |
| 2006 |
Chris West |
Scholar-Athlete |
Men's Soccer |
| 2007 |
Martin McLaughlin |
Scholar-Athlete |
Men's Basketball |
| 2007 |
Cari Wooley |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Basketball |
| 2007 |
Joseph Witzig |
Scholar-Athlete |
Men's Outdoor Track & Field |
| 2007 |
Zinzile Maseko |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Outdoor Track & Field |