| Year |
Name |
Honor |
Sport |
| 1989 |
Sarah Applegate |
All-American |
Women's Swimming & Diving |
| 1994 |
Sarah Applegate |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Swimming & Diving |
| 1995 |
Ben MacDonald |
Player of the Week |
Men's Soccer |
| 1995 |
Erica Brehm |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 1995 |
Camille Morgan |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 1995 |
Maya Salih Raschel |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 1995 |
Kim Wilkins |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 1996 |
Sara Lampo |
All-American |
Women's Swimming & Diving |
| 1996 |
Heidi Baxter |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 1996 |
Erica Brehm |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 1996 |
Yoko Mensing |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 1997 |
Camille Morgan |
Player of the Week |
Women's Soccer |
| 1997 |
Camille Morgan |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 1997 |
Shannon Doran |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Soccer |
| 1998 |
Wade Jerdee |
All-American |
Men's Swimming & Diving |
| 1999 |
Ann Alquist |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Swimming & Diving |
| 2000 |
Bonnie Martin |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Swimming & Diving |
| 2001 |
Misty Westphal |
All-American |
Women's Swimming & Diving |
| 2001 |
Trelton Spenser |
All-American - Third Team |
Division II Men's Basketball |
| 2001 |
Bonnie Martin |
Scholar-Athlete |
Swimming & Diving |
| 2002 |
Quincy Wilder |
All-American - First Team |
Division II Men's Basketball |
| 2002 |
Andre Stewart |
All-American - Second Team |
Division II Men's Basketball |
| 2003 |
Drew Gaede |
Scholar-Athlete |
Swimming & Diving |
| 2004 |
Joe Gjertsen |
All-American - Third Team |
Men's Soccer |
| 2004 |
Joe Gjertson |
All-Tournament Team |
Men's Soccer |
| 2004 |
Josh Klimek |
Scholar-Athlete |
Men's Cross Country |
| 2005 |
Rachel Williams |
Scholar-Athlete |
Women's Cross Country |
| 2005 |
Josh Klimek |
Scholar-Athlete |
Men's Cross Country |
| 2006 |
Team |
Statistical Leader - Scoring Defense |
Division II Men's Basketball |